John Hellerman’s most recent byline, published by O’Dwyer’s PR, shows that news stories are formed by reporters’ working theories shaped by their sources’ incentives, not just neutral facts. Companies (and experts) often answer factual questions while missing the damaging narrative underneath. Legal and communications must collaborate to counter that theory early — and manage how the story mutates after publication.

Read it below or on O’Dywer’s online here.

“A company can answer every factual question accurately while
still allowing a damaging theory to stand untouched.”

The Questions Aren’t the Question

Mon., Nov. 16, 2026

By John Hellerman

It’s 8:42a on a Monday morning and a reporter at a national business publication receives an email alleging that a publicly traded technology company has been hiding serious problems with one of its artificial intelligence products. By Friday morning, the company is on the front page, its stock is down, customers are calling, and the board is asking how the story got so far before management understood what was at stake.

Most executives would describe the intervening four days fairly simply: a reporter received a tip, investigated it, contacted the company, ran the story through editors and lawyers, and published. That is accurate in the same way that saying litigation consists of two sides filing briefs is accurate. What really happened is that people with different information, obligations and incentives spent several days competing, mostly in good faith, over what the facts meant.

Consider a fictional company we’ll call Meridian Technologies. Its AI software helps banks evaluate commercial lending risk. Engineers discover that, under certain circumstances, it sometimes produces inaccurate assessments. Management believes the problem is limited and begins fixing it. One engineer believes the problem is broader, that management has moved too slowly and that her concerns have not been taken seriously. She contacts a reporter.

Everybody Has an Agenda

Executives often ask whether an anonymous or confidential source “has an agenda,” as though the answer might disqualify whatever the source provides. Of course the source has a motivation. A short seller may have excellent information and a financial interest in seeing the stock fall. Motivation matters, but it does not determine whether information is true. What matters is what a source knows, how the source knows it and where personal interests may be shaping what he or she can see.

The reporter begins making calls, reviewing documents and consulting experts. Inevitably, she develops a theory of what happened. Without one, reporting is little more than accumulation; thousands of facts do not become journalism until someone decides which ones matter to the question being investigated. Lawyers do something similar when they develop a theory of the case. Good reporters test that theory; good editors make them do it.

The Questions Are Not the Question

By Wednesday afternoon Meridian receives twelve detailed questions with a deadline the following morning. The CEO’s first instinct is familiar: “This isn’t accurate. Tell her that.” Unfortunately, “that” is rarely precise enough.

The general counsel sees litigation exposure, customer confidentiality, securities obligations, privilege and the possibility that today’s statement may look different in discovery two years from now. Communications sees something else in the questions: the reporter’s working theory.

This is where companies often make one of their most consequential mistakes. They answer the questions but fail to address the theory behind them..

Suppose the reporter asks when Meridian first learned of the problem, how many customers were affected, why all customers were not immediately notified and whether executives discussed whether disclosure could hurt sales. Legal can produce precise answers to each. Communications, however, should recognize the proposition sitting underneath all four: Did Meridian know it had a dangerous problem and conceal it for commercial reasons?

A company can answer every factual question accurately while still allowing a damaging theory to stand untouched.

Where Legal and Communications Meet

Legal and communications are often portrayed as natural adversaries: lawyers want to say nothing; communicators want to say everything. In competent organizations, neither caricature is accurate. Legal is protecting against admissions, waivers, disclosure problems and future litigation. Communications is protecting against a different risk: allowing an incomplete public theory to harden into accepted fact. The mistake is treating either category of risk as though it were the only one that matters.

The better question is not whether legal will “let us talk,” but: What can the company demonstrate without compromising its legal position?

The team identifies records establishing when the issue was discovered, what remediation occurred and why customers received different communications. Legal protects privileged and confidential information; communications organizes the permissible facts around the misunderstanding it needs to correct. The reporter now has evidence that cuts against part of her original theory.

The People You Never See

Late Thursday, the reporter files her draft under the headline “Meridian Concealed Dangerous Flaws in AI Lending System.” Her editor asks whether the reporting actually establishes concealment and whether “dangerous” is supported. A newsroom lawyer tests anonymous-source assertions, corroboration and whether Meridian had a fair opportunity to respond. Their job is to help publish the strongest version of the story the evidence supports.

The headline becomes “Internal Warnings Raise Questions About Meridian’s AI Risk Controls.” Meridian still hates it, but it is a materially different allegation.

Publication Is the Handoff

Friday morning the article appears and immediately begins to mutate. A commentator calls it an “AI cover-up.” A competitor sends it to customers. Other reporters use it as background. The original story becomes source material for stories about the story.

Publication, therefore, is not the end of the communications process. It is the handoff.

If coverage is positive, the work becomes using that third-party validation with customers, employees, recruits, investors and business-development targets rather than admiring the clip and moving on. If it is damaging, the task is to identify which interpretations are likely to travel, which audiences matter, what misconceptions need correcting and whether engagement will clarify the issue or merely give it more oxygen.

A negative article rarely lands as a single blow. It creates follow-on jabs from competitors, commentators, employees, plaintiffs’ lawyers, regulators and other reporters. The communications challenge shifts from influencing one journalist’s understanding to managing how the resulting narrative moves through a much larger ecosystem.

The easiest way to see how much judgment shaped Meridian’s story is to rewind the week and change one decision at a time. Suppose the company refused to engage. Suppose it answered every question without recognizing the theory. Suppose legal and communications treated one another as obstacles.

The product problem would be identical. Public understanding might be dramatically different.

Executives tend to think events create stories. They don’t. Events create evidence. People decide what the evidence means. Responsible journalism surrounds that judgment with corroboration, skepticism, editing, legal review and a meaningful opportunity to respond, but those disciplines do not eliminate judgment; they make it more reliable.

One way for executives to understand that system is to reverse the roles. Put the CEO in the reporter’s chair. Make the general counsel the confidential source. Let communications edit the story. Give everyone different information, responsibilities and incentives but the same facts, and compare the results.

The exercise would probably reveal something more useful than who writes the best headline. It would show how quickly intelligent people can reach different conclusions from the same event, and how much of the eventual news story is determined before the company in question ever receives that first email.

Because by the time the phone rings, somebody else has probably already formed a theory of what the story is about. The company’s first job is to recognize it.

Positioning Professionals

Hellerman Communications is an award-winning corporate communications agency specializing in positioning professionals to win business and navigate crises. With expertise in strategic marketing & content development, crisis & litigation communications, and social influencer & stakeholder relations, we help the world’s most elite professionals and their firms build and protect their most lucrative relationships.

Connect

5335 Wisconsin Avenue NW
Suite 640
Washington, DC 20015

info@hellermanllc.com
202.681.3258

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
Call Now Button